[HPAS Mains & Interview 2014] Matter in the News ! HPPSC defends HPAS Mains & Interview Marking System

In Last Post where I mentioned that HPPSC is manipulating Interview marks We saw a debate where Himachal or Non Himachali issue was discussed, but it was not that much relevant because we saw some Non Himachali getting full marks while the Toppers Like Neeraj Tanwar, Mayank Rana were given least marks in the Interviews. Now question arises if Written toppers were given least marks just because they were Non Himachalis then Veena Thakur, Latika Sehajpal, Anwita Upadhyay Got 100+ marks. As per my knowledge these 3 candidates are Non Himachali and they still Got Highest marks in interviews and in written they have less marks than many others.

So the debate about Himachali or Non Himachali become a different thing here because it shows that
even if you are a hard working Himachali you can't be sure about your hard work and selection if you don't have manipulation methods included in your plans. I know many Hard working Himachali Candidates in this List who were given less marks in the interview than the favoured ones. Now if this is not corruption then what is it ?

What Chairman Says  ?

KS Tomar's Reaction is simply nothing he Say " He can't say anything officially and such things must not be given much attention."

If you can't say anything officially then why are sitting there, why don't you leave the task for better person who can say something. Further his reaction is : such things must not be given much attention. 

Then which things must be given more attention? Favoritism ?
 

This is serious matter the way we choose our officers? How People going to get Good Services when our recruitment Processes are full of favourtism and only focus upon selecting their OWN persons not SUITABLE persons. I always believe a corrupt recruitment system makes system more corrupt and finally whole institution becomes corrupt. Recruitment Corruption is worst kind of Corruption because it further responsible for all other kind of corruptions.

Shameful ! Zero Transparency by HPPSC !


17 comments:

  1. Appreciable effort khadu sir. Weldone

    ReplyDelete
  2. but other state behaveiour is same towards himachali and other states

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think You need to read again what I have written, even then if not able to understand read it again and again. You will finally get my point. Read carefully.

      Delete
    2. Dear Mr Khadubhai
      You have deliberately hidden marks of 2nd optional(civil engg) of written topper, his marks are 242/300, this person got just 53/150 in GS. He topped in written only because of one optional,poor score in GS shows he might have performed poor in interview also,question is why you are indulging in such ill motivated, negative propoganda about HPPSC. HAVE YOU BEEN PAID BY THESE OUTSIDERS???ALSO YOU ARE SPREADING RUMOURS THROUGH NEWSPAPERS DOING MORE HARM THAN GOOD TO CAUSE OF HIMACHALIS.

      Delete
    3. I am not hiding deliberately anything, Its not that Only he scored Good in optionals. Other toppers also Scored High in the optionals. Everyone Knows HPAS is a game of optionals. You can also choose any Subject and score as much as higher you can. So your Point is baseless that his scores are GOOD in optionals. Obviously There are two optional of total 600 marks so its upto the candidates how much they can score. Its not candidate's problem that they only ask 150 marks of GS, because so less weight age has been given to GS, candidates have to focus on optionals more, but that does not mean that they can't prepare GS. Candidates have to adopt according to the pattern and syllabus. Its a HPPSC's problem that they can't create a balanced pattern, its not mine or candidates problem. If tomorrow YOU score Good in optionals and you top in the whole written marks and then get least marks in Interview how you will feel. Its not Himachali or Non Himachal Issue, its issue of transparency and favourtism. There are some non himachalis in the Successful list who got Highest in interview while they got very less in written so it means there is something to think. HPPSC must make system transparent and must ensure they create a pattern and syllabus that's more suitable for Himachalis, then outsiders automatically will not apply or not waste their time and Energy. But Cheating is bad, a Honest outsider OFFICER is better than a favourite insider.

      You must also write to HPPSC regarding Himachali's causes and issues. So that they can also think about it. we need Honest Officers not their OWN people.

      Delete
  3. This is too much. I don't know what are the reasons behind it. But I don't believe in HPPSC. They have flunk me in Compulsory Hindi by two marks. The system is in the hands of corrupt persons.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks khadu bhai for highlighting such matters but these carrier killer criminals will continue this practice untill some legal action will not taken against them. Candidates selected on such previlages will always favour such practice when they will get chance to get such seats.some sort of ligal enquiry must be there for this.and there is nothing to say anything about this TOMAR who refused to say anything which is going under his nose.Anyway i have already sent mail on hppsc website thanking Tomar for his activities in some golden words which will make him stand on his seat if he will read it. Good work by khadu bhai but must do if possible something legally against it to give some diamonds to hp not like stones like Tomar..

    ReplyDelete
  5. You have raised an important issue here sir ! HPPSC is not at all transparent. They manipulate the process as well as marks to select the ones they want. This practice is not only limited to HAS but to all exams conducted by HPPSC

    ReplyDelete
  6. veena thakur is from himachal .

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sir it is done in every exam conducted by hppsc. I hv cleared exams several times but rejected in intrw evrytym. While filing an RTI HPPSC replied that they dont hav any breakup of 100 marka allocated for interview.

    ReplyDelete
  8. In my point of view , rather than giving less marks in interview and kicking the person out of the competition.. Hppsc should not accept other state candidates forms as PSC is in every state i think and one should prepare for his/her state or UPSC .. so that one should not waste time at all.

    ReplyDelete
  9. It is very clear Hppsc is here for just collecting fee .. nothing else.. fee should be rs. 100 like upsc

    ReplyDelete
  10. In Assistant Engineer exam also full corruption is there.Written marks are not added 100 marks interview is sole criteria.Attended interview 4 times qualified Gate exam 3 times 83 % in degree...but of no use here,,they used to take5 to 8 minute interview...selecting candidates without any gate or his past record.. no bifurcation of 100 marks of interview....n biggest frustration is member who used to take interview of A.E. exam is retired from state PWD dept. ..how can u expect honesty from such person who has worked in most corrupted dept

    ReplyDelete
  11. Nice article, recently I had been to interview to HPPSC. The whole process seemed to be mere mockery. They were just interviewing for 10-15 minutes max. from some people they asked very simple questions and from few quite complicated it was clear that the selection was already done and they were doing formality.
    Though I am Himachali but partiality and favoritism was clearly evident.

    ReplyDelete
  12. How much chance do a non-himachali have in HPAS ?
    Is there any recent success story of any such person clearing this exam.

    Please guide friends

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks sir,
      is there any success story by any outsider ?

      Delete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Translate